Explore Wild New York
FISHING  ●  PADDLING  ●  HIKING  ●  BIRDING

Lime Lake Outlet

Lime Lake Outlet, the northern outlet of Lime Lake (yes, there is a small southern outlet), meanders through swamps, woodlands, and open fields for a mere 5.12 miles before flowing into Elton Creek in Delevan. The stream has a gravel bottom, very good water quality, and lots of overhanging bank cover. Much of the stream east of Route 16 is too brushy for fly fishing but is good for bait and spin fishing; open water more suitable for fly fishing is found after the stream flows under Route 16 and is immediately joined by McKinstry Creek, which at least doubles the flow of Lime Lake Outlet. Though rather short and heavily fished, this stream provides some of the best wild trout fishing in western New York. 

Lime Lake Outlet is no longer stocked due to the high numbers of wild trout found here. DEC assessments of this stream show that it has one of the highest biomasses of wild trout in western New York; only Wiscoy Creek, Clear Creek (Ellington), Elm Creek, and possibly Clear Creek (Arcade) equal or surpass it. For a summary of the DEC's 2020 survey of this stream, see Technical Brief under Links.

Wild rainbow trout and brown trout are found throughout this stream, and both species grow to quite respectable size. There are usually more browns than rainbows here, but because rainbows are easier to catch than the more wary browns, expect to hook three or four rainbows for every brown. The brown trout, however, are bigger, sometimes much bigger, and very occasionally some lucky angler will land an 18- to 20-inch brown trout from this stream. This stream also used to have a resident population of wild brook trout, but based on recent trout population surveys, they are no longer found here. However, a small tributary of Lime Lake Outlet is known to still hold a few wild brookies.  

In addition to trout, Lime Lake Outlet also has a surprising number of species you wouldn't expect in a high-quality trout stream. During a trout population survey performed on this stream in 2022, the DEC captured several black crappies and largemouth bass, which undoubtedly managed to get into the stream from Lime Lake.  

To ensure public access to this stream, the DEC has purchased 4.4 miles of public fishing rights along this stream (that's 86 percent of the stream!), from just north of Lime Lake to the village of Delevan. Fisherman parking areas are located on Route 16, 1.4 miles north of Lime Lake (the map pin is located here), and on Regan Street in Delevan. For additional information and a map from the DEC, see Links.

__________________֍__________________ 

A link to associated resource (Lime Lake) will be added soon.

Location Map

Photographs

Lime Lake Outlet begins at a spillway beneath this building located about 80 feet north of Lime Lake. After exiting the building, Lime Lake Outlet flows for about 150 feet before entering a large wetland.
Shortly after exiting the spillway building, Lime Lake Outlet flows into this 31-acre wetland. Many of the warm-water fish that make it over the spillway take up residence here. While photographing this area, I saw numerous largemouth bass, bluegills, and crappies. The wetland was likely created by beavers, as the DEC has obtained extensive public fishing rights along the stream channel in this area.
This partially blown out beaver dam must have been here for quite some time, as for some distance the streambed above the dam is 18 to 24 inches higher than on the downstream side. Upstream of this point, the surroundings become increasingly swampy and difficult to navigate, but the wild trout don't seem to mind.
When hiking along Lime Lake Outlet upstream of the DEC parking area on Route 16, it's best to wear chest waders, not hip waders. As you can see in this photo, the water isn't very deep, but in some place the muck is waist deep, as I found out seconds after I took this photo. Chest waders also provide some protection against the disease-carrying mites and ticks that live in such swampy areas.
Upstream of the crossing of Route 16, one of the most prolific insects found along Lime Lake Outlet is the ebony jewelwing damselfly. Seen here is a mating pair; the female (left) always has a white spot on her wings. These and other damselflies, both the larvae and adults, are an important food source for trout in many New York streams. Trout feed eagerly on these insects if they drop onto the surface of the stream in a slack-water area. See Links for an ebony jewelwing fly recipe.
In August of 2022, the DEC performed a trout population survey of this stream. The section seen here is about 1,000 feet upstream of the DEC parking area on Route 16. Between the outlet on Lime Lake and the crossing at Route 16, about two-thirds of this stream flows through state-regulated wetlands. The section shown here is typical of the terrain through which the stream flows: thick streamside vegetation, marshy surroundings, and a mucky bottom anywhere the stream's flow has been impeded.
A typical wild rainbow trout from Lime Lake Outlet. These beautiful fish are very energetic in the cold water of this stream.
Fish from Lime Lake occasionally make their way into the outlet. This black crappie was captured along with a largemouth bass and smallmouth bass from a pool upstream of Route 16, definitely not their preferred type of water.
This fugitive largemouth bass from Lime Lake was captured by the DEC just upstream of the DEC parking area on Route 16. Two bass were captured that day, and I'm sure we didn't get all of them.
If you're fishing the section of this stream upstream of the DEC parking area on Route 16, take the time to appreciate the surroundings. This wetland area is host to many interesting species of flowers (these are white turtleheads), birds, and insects.
In June of 2019, I spoke at length with the man who owns the property above (seen here) and below Neamon Drive. He encourages people to fish the section of Lime Lake Outlet on his property as long as they don't litter. He also mows paths down to the stream (see at right).
Lime Lake Outlet a short distance upstream of Neamon Drive.
This low waterfall is located a short distance downstream of Neamon Drive. The DEC has purchased public fishing rights for about a third of a mile above and below this point
While most of the brown trout in Lime Lake Outlet are no larger than 10 inches, a few of these fish are bruisers. This fish was captured during a 2022 trout stream survey performed downstream of Worden Road. Brown trout grow well in Lime Lake Outlet due, in part, to the abundant insect life found in and on the stream.
I don't usually fish while studying and photographing streams; I wouldn't get enough work done. But sometimes I do take time for a few casts. I caught this wild and very energetic rainbow somewhere between Worden Road and the DEC parking area on Regan Street in Delevan. Most of the rainbow trout you'll catch in this stream are about this size.
DEC staff and volunteers working a large pool on Lime Lake Outlet just upstream of Mill Street in Delevan during the trout population survey performed in August of 2022. Pools formed by large woody debris (LWD) provide essential habit for adult trout, a number of which were captured here.
This was probably the largest brown trout captured near Mill Street during the 2022 trout population survey. It measured about 18 inches.
A DEC shocking crew working on a section of Lime Lake Outlet downstream of Mill Street in Delevan. The stream begins to widen as it flows north of Mill Street and is shallow, but there are many pockets of deeper water.

Resource Map

See Location Map and DEC public fishing rights map (under Links). Note that the stocking and regulations information presented with the PFR map may be out of date. See the stocking list and regulations guide for current information.

Driving Directions


Access

Road Access:

Lime Lake Outlet is roughly paralleled by Route 16. DEC parking areas are available along Route 16, 1.4 miles north of Lime Lake, and on Regan Street off Mill Street in Delevan. See the DEC brochure under Links for a map of the extensive public fishing rights along the stream.

Boat Launch Site(s):

None.

Weather

Fishery Management

Management Category: Inland Trout Stream, Wild-Premier: From the confluence with Elton Creek upstream to Lime Lake, a distance of 5.3 miles.

Fish Species:

  • Rainbow Trout (wild)
  • Brown Trout (wild)
  • Largemouth Bass
  • Black Crappie

Stocking Information: Not stocked.

Special Fishing Regulations: Wild-Premier trout stream regulations apply. See regulations guide.

 

Copyright 2023 Sander's Fishing Guides, Inc.

; ;