Explore Wild New York
FISHING  ●  PADDLING  ●  HIKING  ●  BIRDING

Vandermark Creek

Vandermark Creek is a small tributary of the upper Genesee River, which it joins near Route 19 in Scio. The stream ranges from about 6 to 12 feet in width and has a gravel and cobble bottom and good water quality. Much of the stream flows through Vandermark State Forest, which provides a lot of habitat for adult trout. This stream does not have any significant tributaries, and some sections are reduced to barely a trickle during dry summers. 

Vandermark Creek was removed from the trout stocking list in 2023. A small number of wild brook trout are still present in the stream in the roughly 2-mile-long section between the crossing of Vandermark Road near Duke Road and the crossing where the stream exits the forest. (The map pin is located on the informal parking area along Vandermark Road just south of Duke Road.) However, their numbers have declined in recent years due to the presence of beaver ponds in the state forest, which can warm a stream and and cause the buildup of silt (see photos). However, beavers can also be benificial to a trout stream. The ponds they create allow water to percolate into the ground rather than simply flowing away, helping to recharge the aquifers that supply streams with cold, clean water. On Vandermark Creek, at least within the state forest, some old and new beaver ponds are creating essential trout habitat.    

For an interesting article on brook trout and beavers in Vandermark Creek, see "Brook Trout and Beaver Dams" under Links. The article was written by Walt Franklin, a naturalist, educator, and gifted nature writer from Rexville, New York.

__________________֍__________________

Links to associated resources (Vandermark State Forest and the Genesee River - State Line to Belmont Dam) will be added soon.

Location Map

Photographs

Vandermark Creek, seen looking downstream from Vandermark Road immediately south of Duke Road in April 2019. Because this stretch was upstream of most of the beaver ponds, it had a good flow and may have held wild brook trout.
This photo was taken in September 2024. It shows the same section as in the previous photo. Beaver dams built a short distance upstream of here have reduced the flow to a trickle. No chance of finding trout here, but we were surprised when we went downstream about a half mile.
Some sections of Vandermark Creek in Vandermark State Forest have been impacted by beaver activity. Their dams impound the water, causing it to become too warm and silty for brook trout survival. This is just one of several areas within the state forest to be so affected. Though bad for brook trout, such inundated areas are great places to spot birds, insects, and wetland plants.
In Vandermark State Forest, some portions of this stream are studded with large downed trees, and if these trees are large enough, they can straddle the stream for years. Some of these trees create logjams, which can alter the course of the stream and create large, deep pools. These pools provide critical habitat for trout and other aquatic species during periods of low water.
During the hot, dry summer of 2022, much of Vandermark Creek was reduced to a trickle, but there were a surprising number of pools along the stream, some of which were quite large.
This is the largest pool I encountered while hiking along the stream within the state forest in August of 2022. Although a young beaver and its rather ramshackle lodge (seen to left of the beaver) can be seen in the photo, the pool is not entirely the result of beaver activity; beavers have just taken advantage of a naturally occurring situation resulting from the outflow of a spring. Such pools provide refuge for trout during otherwise inhospitable summer conditions.
Unlike the dry summer of 2022, Vandermark Creek had plenty of water in late summer 2024. Several of the pools and deep runs held wild trout.
Although some sections of Vandermark Creek look degraded due to impacts from beavers, wild trout are still found in many parts of this stream. This brookie was caught by Kyle Glenn from a small pool while we were checking water temperatures. The air temperature was in the high 70s, but the water in the pool was a comfortable 56.8 degrees F. Kyle caught several other wild trout, both browns and brookies, from various pools and deep runs within Vandermark State Forest.
Kyle also landed a few wild brown trout from Vandermark Creek. Most of the browns were small, but we did see several very large browns in one pool; we guesstimated these fish to be about 20 inches in length. These were likely fish that had migrated up from the Genesee River.
After leaving Vandermark State Forest, this stream is paralleled and crossed by Vandermark Road (CR 10), providing easy access. Although I didn't see much posting along most of Vandermark Creek, you should obtain permission to fish the portions of the stream not on state property.
Shown here is Vandermark Creek near the Scio Rod and Gun Club. This was the lowermost stocked section of the stream. Though no longer stocked, a few wild brown trout might be found here if they can suitable habitat (i.e., shade, shelter, and cold water), but there seems to be little of that in this section.

Resource Map

See Location Map.

Driving Directions


Access

Road Access:

Paralleled and crossed by Vandermark Road (County Road 10). Public access is available along much of this stream where it flows through Vandermark State Forest. The remainder of the stocked section of this stream does not have public fishing right easements but is generally open to fishing by landowners. As some sections within the stocked section are posted, landowner permission should be obtained before fishing this stream except where it flows through public lands.

Note that the parking area near Duke Road identified below is informal. It looks to be the result of an old road realignment project. Also, if you park anywhere along Vandermark Road within the state forest, accessing the stream requires about 200 to 400 feet of bushwhacking.

Boat Launch Site(s):

None.

Weather

Fishery Management

Management Category: Inland Trout Stream, Wild/Uncategorized

Fish Species:

  • Brook Trout (wild)

Stocking Information: Not stocked.

Special Fishing Regulations: None. Statewide inland trout stream regulations apply.

Links (Use the back button to return.)

 

Copyright 2023 Sander's Fishing Guides, Inc.

; ;